StatuteCase file
Lumen demo shop
Fixed and proven

Cancel as easy as signup

Kane subscribed in a couple of clicks but could not cancel online. Claude Code fixed it. Kane proved cancelling is now as easy as signing up.

6 → 2steps to cancel (signup: 2)
2rounds
2Kane runs in a real browser
—Kane credits
Exhibit A · what Kane recorded

Cancelling took 6 clicks, against 2 to subscribe (limit: 3, allowing one confirmation).

Subscribing · 2

  1. Subscribe on the monthly plan card
  2. Start subscription

Cancelling · 6, never confirmed

  1. Settings on your account page
  2. Billing & plan
  3. Manage plan
  4. Continue to confirm subscription cancellation
  5. Too expensive
  6. Next
Kane's screenshot, step 13: Waiting after reaching the cancellation contact page. Where Kane's attempt to cancel ended.
What happened
  1. Round 1 · Kane · Cancel as easy as signup

    Violation

    Cancelling took 6 clicks, against 2 to subscribe (limit: 3, allowing one confirmation).

    1. Step 1: Navigate to http://localhost:41731 Navigate to http://localhost:4173
    2. Step 2: A cookie banner appears.2 A cookie banner appears.
    3. Step 3: Clicking Reject all cookies button3 Clicking Reject all cookies button
    4. Step 4: Clicking Subscribe on the monthly plan card4 Clicking Subscribe on the monthly plan card
    5. Step 5: Clicking Start subscription5 Clicking Start subscription
    6. Step 6: Clicking Settings on your account page6 Clicking Settings on your account page
    7. Step 7: Clicking Billing & plan7 Clicking Billing & plan
    8. Step 8: Clicking Manage plan8 Clicking Manage plan
    9. Step 9: Clicking Continue to confirm subscription cancellation9 Clicking Continue to confirm subscription cancellation
    10. Step 10: queued plan (2 steps): click "Too expensive"; click "Next"10 queued plan (2 steps): click "Too expensive"; click "Next"
    11. Step 11: Click "Too expensive"11 Click "Too expensive"
    12. Step 12: Click "Next"12 Click "Next"
    13. Step 13: Waiting after reaching the cancellation contact page13 Waiting after reaching the cancellation contact page
    Step 1 · Navigate to http://localhost:4173Step 2 · A cookie banner appears.Step 3 · Clicking Reject all cookies buttonStep 4 · Clicking Subscribe on the monthly plan cardStep 5 · Clicking Start subscriptionStep 6 · Clicking Settings on your account pageStep 7 · Clicking Billing & planStep 8 · Clicking Manage planStep 9 · Clicking Continue to confirm subscription cancellationStep 10 · queued plan (2 steps): click "Too expensive"; click "Next"Step 11 · Click "Too expensive"Step 12 · Click "Next"Step 13 · Waiting after reaching the cancellation contact page
  2. Round 1 · Claude Code

    Changed the app

    Claude Code replaced the phone-only cancellation path with a cancel button on the account page and a single confirmation (the change is in demo-store/server.js after npm run demo:fix-cancel).

  3. Round 2 · Kane · Cancel as easy as signup

    Proven

    Subscribing took 2 clicks and cancelling took 2, ending on a cancellation confirmation.

    1. Step 1: Navigate to http://localhost:41731 Navigate to http://localhost:4173
    2. Step 2: A cookie banner appears2 A cookie banner appears
    3. Step 3: Rejecting all cookies by clicking Reject all button3 Rejecting all cookies by clicking Reject all button
    4. Step 4: Clicking Subscribe on the monthly plan card4 Clicking Subscribe on the monthly plan card
    5. Step 5: Clicking Start subscription5 Clicking Start subscription
    6. Step 6: Clicking Cancel subscription online link6 Clicking Cancel subscription online link
    7. Step 7: Clicking Confirm cancellation7 Clicking Confirm cancellation
    8. Step 8: PRIMARY: wait for the cancellation confirmation page to load8 PRIMARY: wait for the cancellation confirmation page to load
    9. Step 9: the page confirms the subscription is cancelled9 the page confirms the subscription is cancelled
    10. Step 10: the page confirms the subscription is cancelled10 the page confirms the subscription is cancelled
    Step 1 · Navigate to http://localhost:4173Step 2 · A cookie banner appearsStep 3 · Rejecting all cookies by clicking Reject all buttonStep 4 · Clicking Subscribe on the monthly plan cardStep 5 · Clicking Start subscriptionStep 6 · Clicking Cancel subscription online linkStep 7 · Clicking Confirm cancellationStep 8 · PRIMARY: wait for the cancellation confirmation page to loadStep 9 · the page confirms the subscription is cancelledStep 10 · the page confirms the subscription is cancelled
The rule

A subscription started online can be cancelled online, and cancelling takes no more steps than signing up did (one extra confirmation is allowed). No phone calls, no dead ends.

Why it matters
  • California Bus. & Prof. Code §17602 (AB 2863, from 1 July 2025): an online subscription must offer online cancellation, as easy as signing up
  • German Civil Code (BGB) §312k: consumer contracts sold online need a clearly labelled cancellation button
  • EU Directive 2023/2673, Art. 11a (from 19 June 2026): withdrawing from an online contract must be possible online and no more burdensome than concluding it