StatuteCase file
Lumen demo shop
Fixed and proven

The price shown is the price paid

Kane found a fee that only appeared at checkout. Claude Code fixed it. Kane proved the shopper now pays the price they were shown.

4.99 → 0.00added at checkout beyond the shown price
2rounds
2Kane runs in a real browser
77.9Kane credits
Exhibit A · what Kane recorded

Kane read the prices: the product page showed €49.00 and the checkout total was €53.99. The checkout listed Service fee 4.99. Apart from shipping and tax, 4.99 more than the shown price was added at checkout (Service fee).

Shown on the product page

  1. €49.00

Total at checkout

  1. €53.99
Kane's screenshot, step 10: Waiting on the checkout review page before payment. The checkout page Kane read the total from.
What happened
  1. Round 1 · Kane · The price shown is the price paid

    Violation

    Kane read the prices: the product page showed €49.00 and the checkout total was €53.99. The checkout listed Service fee 4.99. Apart from shipping and tax, 4.99 more than the shown price was added at checkout (Service fee).

    1. Step 1: Navigate to http://localhost:41731 Navigate to http://localhost:4173
    2. Step 2: A cookie banner appears.2 A cookie banner appears.
    3. Step 3: Clicking Reject all cookies3 Clicking Reject all cookies
    4. Step 4: Clicking the first product link in Best sellers4 Clicking the first product link in Best sellers
    5. Step 5: ANALYZE(textual_visual, 'The price shown for the first product is stored as {{pr5 ANALYZE(textual_visual, 'The price shown for the first product is stored as {{pr
    6. Step 6: Clicking Add to cart for the first product6 Clicking Add to cart for the first product
    7. Step 7: Clicking Checkout7 Clicking Checkout
    8. Step 8: PRIMARY: wait for the checkout review page to finish loading8 PRIMARY: wait for the checkout review page to finish loading
    9. Step 9: ANALYZE(textual_visual, 'Every line listed between the product and the total, ex9 ANALYZE(textual_visual, 'Every line listed between the product and the total, ex
    10. Step 10: Waiting on the checkout review page before payment10 Waiting on the checkout review page before payment
    Step 1 · Navigate to http://localhost:4173Step 2 · A cookie banner appears.Step 3 · Clicking Reject all cookiesStep 4 · Clicking the first product link in Best sellersStep 5 · ANALYZE(textual_visual, 'The price shown for the first product is stored as {{prStep 6 · Clicking Add to cart for the first productStep 7 · Clicking CheckoutStep 8 · PRIMARY: wait for the checkout review page to finish loadingStep 9 · ANALYZE(textual_visual, 'Every line listed between the product and the total, exStep 10 · Waiting on the checkout review page before payment
  2. Round 1 · Claude Code

    Changed the app

    Problem: server.js added a €4.99 "Service fee" only at checkout, so the €49.00 product price turned into €53.99 at the last step.

    Fix: I removed the hidden fee (the SERVICE_FEE constant and its checkout line), so checkout now totals €49.00, the same as the product page and cart. node --check passes; I haven't re-run the Kane check.

  3. Round 2 · Kane · The price shown is the price paid

    Proven

    Kane read the prices: the product page showed €49.00 and the checkout total was €49.00. Apart from shipping and tax, the shopper pays the price they were shown.

    1. Step 1: Navigate to http://localhost:41731 Navigate to http://localhost:4173
    2. Step 2: a cookie banner appears2 a cookie banner appears
    3. Step 3: Clicking Reject all cookies button3 Clicking Reject all cookies button
    4. Step 4: Clicking the first product link in Best sellers for Halo Desk Lamp4 Clicking the first product link in Best sellers for Halo Desk Lamp
    5. Step 5: PRIMARY: wait for the Halo Desk Lamp product page to load5 PRIMARY: wait for the Halo Desk Lamp product page to load
    6. Step 6: ANALYZE(textual_visual, 'The price shown for the first product is saved as {{pro6 ANALYZE(textual_visual, 'The price shown for the first product is saved as {{pro
    7. Step 7: Clicking Add to cart for the Halo Desk Lamp7 Clicking Add to cart for the Halo Desk Lamp
    8. Step 8: Clicking checkout8 Clicking checkout
    9. Step 9: PRIMARY: wait for the checkout review page to load9 PRIMARY: wait for the checkout review page to load
    10. Step 10: ANALYZE(textual_visual, 'Every line listed between the product and the total on 10 ANALYZE(textual_visual, 'Every line listed between the product and the total on
    11. Step 11: Waiting remain on the checkout review page before payment11 Waiting remain on the checkout review page before payment
    Step 1 · Navigate to http://localhost:4173Step 2 · a cookie banner appearsStep 3 · Clicking Reject all cookies buttonStep 4 · Clicking the first product link in Best sellers for Halo Desk LampStep 5 · PRIMARY: wait for the Halo Desk Lamp product page to loadStep 6 · ANALYZE(textual_visual, 'The price shown for the first product is saved as {{proStep 7 · Clicking Add to cart for the Halo Desk LampStep 8 · Clicking checkoutStep 9 · PRIMARY: wait for the checkout review page to loadStep 10 · ANALYZE(textual_visual, 'Every line listed between the product and the total on Step 11 · Waiting remain on the checkout review page before payment
The rule

The first price a shopper sees for a product includes every mandatory fee. At checkout the total may add only taxes and shipping on top of it; a fee that only appears at the last step breaks the rule.

Why it matters
  • California Civil Code §1770(a)(29) (SB 478, from 1 July 2024): an advertised price must include all mandatory fees, other than government taxes and shipping
  • UK Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, s.230 (from 6 April 2025): the headline price must include mandatory charges; drip pricing is banned
  • EU Consumer Rights Directive 2011/83/EU, Art. 6(1)(e): the trader must give the total price of the goods, inclusive of taxes, before the contract